Re: First Taste of CoC...
Posted: Mon Oct 15, 2018 3:49 pm
extensive and expensive or deep and cheap ?
I really like the rules. Getting repeated double 6's is unlikely but clearly possible. I have heard that some people reduced the number of command dice to make it less likely or otherwise house rule it. I've never found it enough of an issue to worry though.
What CoC does encourage is to think more thoroughly about your command options than you normally tend to in war-games. You tend to think of a plan that doesn't leave you exposed if you don't get the run of dice. Caution, patience and combined arms are usually the order of the day (as WW2 often was). So Purp's crispy fried field run is best done by waiting until you do roll a double 6 and then sprinting in conjunction with suppression fire. Or - instead - outflanking in cover.
I like Bolt Action as well though. I don't subscribe to the view pushed in quite a few wargaming circles that you are only allowed to like one or the other. Bolt Action is more heroic, more in your face and faster moving. It doesn't present the same command challenges though. I'd happily play either.
I really like the rules. Getting repeated double 6's is unlikely but clearly possible. I have heard that some people reduced the number of command dice to make it less likely or otherwise house rule it. I've never found it enough of an issue to worry though.
What CoC does encourage is to think more thoroughly about your command options than you normally tend to in war-games. You tend to think of a plan that doesn't leave you exposed if you don't get the run of dice. Caution, patience and combined arms are usually the order of the day (as WW2 often was). So Purp's crispy fried field run is best done by waiting until you do roll a double 6 and then sprinting in conjunction with suppression fire. Or - instead - outflanking in cover.
I like Bolt Action as well though. I don't subscribe to the view pushed in quite a few wargaming circles that you are only allowed to like one or the other. Bolt Action is more heroic, more in your face and faster moving. It doesn't present the same command challenges though. I'd happily play either.